Completed PE Summary

Overseas Camar

Category: Merchant Vessels
Vessel name: Overseas Camar
Manager: OSG Ship Management Group (Greece) Ltd
Ship Owner: Ranch Shipholding
Port of Registry: Majuro
Flag: Marshall Islands
Classification Society: Lloyd's Register
Type: Chemical/Products Tanker
Built: 1988
Construction: Steel
Length overall: 171.80m
Gross tonnage: 26,113
Date & Time: 21 June 2008, 1348
Location of incident: Fawley Marine Terminal, Southampton
Incident Type: Machinery failure
Persons onboard: 27
Injuries/fatalities: Bosun suffered severe bruising to the head and a broken left leg
Damage/pollution: Provisions crane on the starboard aft quarter became detached from its mountings and fell onto a stores barge below, crushing a skip before falling into the sea.

Synopsis

Overseas Camar was loading a cargo of gas oil at the Fawley Marine Terminal near Southampton. The vessel was expecting to load ship’s stores and in accordance with the Terminal’s regulations, a stores barge was alongside at the starboard (outboard) quarter.

The Bosun climbed up onto the operating platform attached to the side of the starboard provisions crane. The crane had a safe working load (SWL) of 0.8 tonne and had successfully passed the five yearly load test and annual inspection conducted by the vessel’s classification society. The first load of hydraulic oil drums was lifted safely, a second load of oil weighing 788kg was attached, and the Bosun began to hoist. The load was lifted approximately 1.8m and suddenly began to lower back to the deck of the stores barge. The crewman on the stores barge looked up and saw both the crane and the Bosun falling. He shouted to the Skipper of the stores barge, who had been steadying the load, and both men ran clear. The crane struck the side of the ship, crushed a skip on the stores barge and fell into the sea. It was initially thought that the Bosun had fallen into the sea, however, he landed on a lifeboat deck, some 5m below the crane pedestal. Although his injuries were severe, he was extremely fortunate not to have fallen further and been killed.

The nuts and bolts used to hold the crane pedestal to the mounting ring were recovered and examined. They were badly corroded, allowing the bolts to pull straight through the nuts. Both the ship’s planned maintenance and the classification society regulations stated that the holding down nuts and bolts should be examined at prerequisite intervals, however the extent of the corrosion indicates that these safeguards had systematically failed over a number of years.

Action taken:

Two other cranes on board were inspected and both found to be in poor condition. Prohibition notices were issued by Port State Control officers and Conditions of Class imposed by the classification society, regarding future use of these cranes.

In addition, the Deputy Chief Inspector of Marine Accidents has written to:

  • the vessel’s management company, detailing the shortcomings in maintenance and inspection that allowed the condition of the crane holding down nuts and bolts to go undetected, and

  • the vessel’s classification society, raising concerns over the effectiveness of the current survey and testing procedures for ship’s cranes.

Published: AUGUST 2008